Supreme Court rejects Edward Snowden's lawsuit for safe passage to Norway

rejected_nov_heading-copy

Supreme Court rejects Edward Snowden’s lawsuit for safe passage to Norway

Whistleblower Edward Snowden’s lawsuit against the Norwegian state to establish that Norway has no right to extradite him to the United States, was rejected by the Supreme Court yesterday. Snowden has, with Norwegian PEN and the Norwegian press organizations as intervention parties, sued the Norwegian state to ensure a safe passage to Norway to receive the Ossietzky prize for 2016 in Oslo.

– Just as Carl von Ossietzky in his time was not permitted to come to Norway to receive the Nobel Peace Prize, Snowden has been prevented from coming here to receive the Ossietzky Prize. Our battle is lost, but the long term goal remains the same: that Edward Snowden, and others who report misconduct, must be able to do so this without fear of prosecution and in the worst case, life imprisonment, says William Nygaard, President of Norwegian PEN.

Norwegian PEN, in collaboration with PEN International, will intensify their efforts to shed light on the whistleblower’s lack of protection in international law. Equally important is to prove that mass surveillance is a threat to our freedoms as individuals. Efforts to protect Edward Snowden’s position as a whistleblower and human rights advocate will prevail.

In what appears to be political loyalty to the US, the Norwegian government decided to not confirm that Snowden could come to Norway without fear of extradition. Thus, the request had to be tried in court. The lawsuit has been tried by the District Court and Court of Appeal with negative outcome. The verdict was upheld by the Supreme Court.

The court’s main argument is that the US government has only requested extradition if Snowden comes to Norway, furthermore that the formal extradition request has not been handed over to Norwegian authorities. Thus, the lawsuit is basically rejected on formal grounds.

Norwegian PEN will travel to Moscow to give the award to Edward Snowden.

Contact:
William Nygaard, head of the Norwegian PEN: +47 908 92 601
Hege Newth Nouri, General Secretary of Norwegian PEN: +47 930 02 262

 

Snowden case: The State tries to gag a dissenting free voice

PRESS RELEASE FROM NORWEGIAN PEN:
On 21st April 2016, Edward Snowden filed a lawsuit, with Norwegian PEN as the intervention party, against the State by the Ministry of Justice and Public Security. The action’s purpose is to legally establish that Norway has no right to extradite Snowden to the United States. Snowden’s alleged crime consists of having exposed mass surveillance under the auspices of the American intelligence agency, the NSA. His actions are of a political nature and he cannot therefore be extradited to the United States, according to the Norwegian Extradition Act and International Law.

On 18th May the State, by the Ministry of Justice and Public Security, delivered a response to our writ of summons. In the defence’s reply, the Attorney General seeks to dismiss the lawsuit on formal grounds. Then State argues that the case should be handled in accordance with criminal procedure and the plaintiff’s civil action cannot be initiated on formal grounds.

Norwegian PEN stresses that the State has not acknowledged the core issue: the recognition of the political nature of Edward Snowden’s actions, and consequently the necessity of his guaranteed safe arrival in Norway to receive the Ossietzky prize without danger of extradition.

The fact that the State, on formal grounds, is attempting to avoid a judicial review of the Extradition Act and secure Edward Snowden’s safe passage to Norway, confirms the importance of the case from a freedom of expression point of view. The outcome could lead to the gagging of a historically important free voice.

By awarding Edward Snowden the Ossietzky prize, Norwegian PEN seeks to create a debate surrounding the international legal framework on mass surveillance.  We seek to protect and strengthen the role of whistleblowers nationally and internationally and to praise Snowden’s unselfish and personal integrity and courage by warning us all against illegal surveillance.

In a letter from Oslo City Court of 19 May, the plaintiff is granted the opportunity to submit comments to the State’s response before 26 May.

The case is being diligently pursued by our lawyers, Halvard Helle and Emanuel Feinberg at Advokatfirmaet Schjødt.

Contact Norwegian PEN:
William Nygaard, President: 90892601
Hege Newth Nouri, Secretary General; 93002262

Contact Advokatfirmaet Schjødt:
Halvard Helle, Partner: 22018800
Emanuel Feinberg, lawyer: 22018800