6. og 7. mai: No Platforming and Free Expression

No Platforming and Free Expression

 

6th and 7th of May 2019, Oslo
Met
Venue: Athene1, Pilestredet 46

No Platforming has been much debated across the world due to instances, where individuals have been barred from participating as university speakers, in public panels, and other fora. Opponents to No platforming highlight the dangers of muting controversial voices and fear it can undermine free expression. This conference attempts to address some of the controversies in open and constructive exchanges, and has invited speakers and panelists from several countries, representing a variety of views and experiences.

 

MONDAY 6 May

 

09.00 – 09.30: Welcome: Norwegian PEN. Knut Olav Åmås, Free Expression Foundation, Elisabeth Eide, JMIC

09:30-1045: Keynote: Eric Heinze, Professor at the School of Law, Queen Mary University of London: An anti-libertarian defence of free speech

Discussants: Lars Gule, Associate Professor at OsloMet; Nora Mehsen, writer/freelancer. Moderator: Ingrid Fadnes

1045-1115: Coffee/Tea break

1115-1230: Panel 1: Sense and sensitivity: Freedom of expression and discrimination: borderline areas (Norwegian)

Arguments have been raised defending No Platforming for people who issue threats and discriminate people of minority; but will such practices undermine freedom of expression?

Camara Lundestad Joof, writer, artist; Shazia Majid, journalist, VG; Lena Andersson, writer and journalist; Mina Adampour, medical doctor & writer; Moderator: Anne Birgitta Nilsen

1230-1320: Lunch break

1320-1350: Shortnote: Niels Ivar Larsen, journalist at Information, Denmark: No Platforming: From Weimar Republic Germany to the Millenials.

1350-1440: The conversation: Emergence from Dictatorship to Democracy & the Rise of Extremisms. In both these countries, with a long history of dictatorship, the transition to democracy has opened the door for extremist mobilization and recruitment. How to face these dilemmas?

Associate professor and journalist Ade Armando. Indonesia; journalist/writer Essia Atrous, Tunisia. Moderator: Lars Gule, OsloMet

1440-1500: Coffee/Tea break

1500-1600: Panel 2: Gender trouble: Platforming, gender, and #metoo (Nordic languages). Discussions of the #metoo campaign addressed many issues, such as ‘outing’ or how much platform should be given to the accused. Are aspects of this campaign questionable?

Ane Stø from Ottar Feminist group; Maren Fuchsia Celius-Blix, writer, commentator; Lena Andersson, writer and journalist. Moderator: Tine Eide, OsloMet

1600 – 1630: Refreshments

16.30 – 19.00:  Afternoon event: The largest platforms (social media) on Earth.

Screening of movie “The Cleaners”, which shows how young workers in the Philippines moderate social media with little contextual knowledge and immense time pressure; what are the consequences?

Peter Münster, Facebook Norway. Moderator: Bente Kalsnes, OsloMet

1930: Joint dinner

 

TUESDAY 7 May

0900-1000: The conversation: Platforms for which extremists? In countries with ongoing war and/or violent conflict: Do reporters give voice to the extremists responsible for the violent acts?

Quatrina Hosein, activist/journalist, Karachi, Pakistan; Ahmedur Rashid Chowdury (‘Tutul’), Editor of Shuddashahr Magazine, Bangladesh/Norway (Ossietzky Award winner 2018). Moderator: Atta Ansari, reporter, NRK

1000-1030: Coffee/Tea break

1030-1200: Panel 3: From fields of violence: How to deal with violent extremists when reporting? Sometimes their statements are readily available, sometimes reporters are offered an ‘embed’ with them.

Afshin Ismaeli, reporter, Aftenposten; Abeer Saady, reporter & Ph D fellow, Egypt and Germany, Pål Refsdal, documentary filmmaker; Dr. Anna M. Grøndahl Larsen, OsloMet;. Moderator: Ingerid Salvesen, OsloMet

1200-1300: Lunch break

1300-1415: Panel 4: Discrimination and moderation. Media institutions have been criticized for offering platforms to speakers considered as extremists. Where do editors draw the line? (Norsk)

Hans Rustad, editor, Document.no; Mari Skurdal, editor-in-chief, Klassekampen; Ingeborg Senneset, journalist, author, board member, Norwegian PEN; Ervin Kohn, deputy director, The Norwegian Center against Racism. Moderator: Elisabeth Eide, OsloMet

1415-1445: Coffee/Tea break

1445-1615: Panel 5: Literature, art and borderlines: Literature and art meet religious and political resistance. Free literature and art meet with resistance in many countries of the world, some for being too ‘explicit’ and some for being explicitly close to known reality.

Andina Dwifatma, writer, Indonesia; Anne-Cécile Sibué-Birkeland, Theatre Director at Black Box; Knut Olav Åmås, Director, Free Expression Foundation; Deise Nunes, artistic director for Golden Mirrors Arts Norway and project developer; Moderator: Andreas Delsett, program coordinator, Oslo House of Literature

1615-1630: Short roundup (two invitees, assigned as ‘reporters’)

ARR: JMIC/OSLOMET, i samarbeid med Norsk PEN og Fritt Ord

Women journalists and free expression

At the 100th anniversary of women’s suffrage in Norway, Norwegian PEN, in co-operation with Department of Journalism and Media studies, Oslo and Akershus University College, hosted the conference «Women’s Suffrage – Women’s voices». Invitees were journalists and journalism educators/researchers from the following countries: Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Egypt, Indonesia, Pakistan, Tunisia and Turkey. The women contributed information and stories on how women are represented in the media in the variety of countries, and on the challenges facing women in countries in transition. Particular emphasis was paid to the tense situation in Turkey, as it unfolded hour by hour as we met. Zeynep Oral and Nadire Mater, both exceptional journalists from Turkey, provided in-depth insight into the current situation for women’s rights, while asking people to address the situation of the many men and women currently jailed for their journalism and writing in general.

Many other speakers addressed the invisibility of women in mainstream media as well as difficulties in being allowed to cover the same beats as their male colleagues. Norwegian journalists and researchers took part in the dialogues, which addressed media content, access to leadership positions in the media, social and judicial constraints in journalism, and a multitude of other issues. Abeer Saady, Amal Wahab, Hamida el Bour and Atidel Mejbri provided powerful examples from the situation in Egypt and Tunisia, where fundamentalists in power try to curb women’s rights. Towards the end, the conference discussed the gender impact of social media, including both positive impact and harassment of women in particular, and experienced well-known Tunisian blogger Lina Ben Mhenni drew on her experiences from the Tunisian revolution. The group of women also paid a visit to the parliament, and there briefly met with several politicians, including Prime Minister Jens Stoltenberg.

Kvinnelige journalister og ytringsfrihet

At the 100th anniversary of women’s suffrage in Norway, Norwegian PEN, in co-operation with Department of Journalism and Media studies, Oslo and Akershus University College, hosted the conference «Women’s Suffrage – Women’s voices». Invitees were journalists and journalism educators/researchers from the following countries: Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Egypt, Indonesia, Pakistan, Tunisia and Turkey. The women contributed information and stories on how women are represented in the media in the variety of countries, and on the challenges facing women in countries in transition. Particular emphasis was paid to the tense situation in Turkey, as it unfolded hour by hour as we met. Zeynep Oral and Nadire Mater, both exceptional journalists from Turkey, provided in-depth insight into the current situation for women’s rights, while asking people to address the situation of the many men and women currently jailed for their journalism and writing in general.

Many other speakers addressed the invisibility of women in mainstream media as well as difficulties in being allowed to cover the same beats as their male colleagues. Norwegian journalists and researchers took part in the dialogues, which addressed media content, access to leadership positions in the media, social and judicial constraints in journalism, and a multitude of other issues.Abeer Saady, Amal Wahab, Hamida el Bour and Atidel Mejbri provided powerful examples from the situation in Egypt and Tunisia, where fundamentalists in power try to curb women’s rights. Towards the end, the conference discussed the gender impact of social media, including both positive impact and harassment of women in particular, and experienced well-known Tunisian bloggerLina Ben Mhenni drew on her experiences from the Tunisian revolution. The group of women also paid a visit to the parliament, and there briefly met with several politicians, including Prime MinisterJens Stoltenberg.